1.Thought of Deming
In his fourteen principles, he requires management not to depend on
inspection.
Quality is made in processes, not by inspections. Improved processes
with trained workers assure good quality. It reduces defective products
and wasteful inspection cost.
2.Thought of Quality assurance by inspection in ISO9001: 1987
Influenced strongly by BS5750, ISO9001: 1987 had made based on the
thought of quality assurance by inspection, not by improving processes.
For instance it has special 4.1.2.2 clause of verification resources
and personnel and it says as follows.
gThe supplier (organization in ISO9001: 2000) shall identify in-house
verification requirements, provide adequate resources and assign trained
personnel for verification activities.
Verification activities shall include inspection, test and monitoring
of the design, production, installation and servicing processes and/or
product; design reviews and audits of the quality system (quality
management system in ISO9001: 2000), processes and/or product shall
be carried by personnel independent of those having direct responsibility
for the work being performedh.
But training of workers who made quality should be more emphasized
than inspectors.
And inspection done by independent personnel of those having direct
responsibility for the work being performed, makes the working people
indifference to quality they made.
3. Retreat from the thought of quality assurance by inspection in
ISO9001: 1994
In 1994 version, 4.1.2.2 is deleted and also independency of those
having direct responsibility for the work being performed is deleted,
except for internal audits.
4.10.2 b) clause of in-process inspection and testing in ISO9001:
1987, which says the organization shall establish product conformance
to specified requirements by use of process monitoring and control
method, is also deleted.
There appeared the word of g self inspectionh in ISO8402: 1994.
4. QS9000
Influenced by Toyota production system, QS9000 (the first edition
issued in 1994) requires in 4.10.3 c) clause that all process activities
should be directed towards defect prevention methods, such as statistical
process control, error proofing, visual controls, rather than defect
prevention.
5. Application of the thought of separation of the three powers to
an organization
For a manufacturing company the legislature power corresponds to the
design and development power, the administration power to the manufacturing
power and the judicial power to the inspection power.
But this thought is obsolete from the standpoint of Total Quality
Management.
|